Do an organization’s values influence the mindsets and actions of its members?


I was brought up short this week by a post condemning values.

Or rather, values statements by organizations.

Paul Sweeney, on his Disruption Space blog, used an excerpt from his book Magnetic Nonsense: A Short History of Bullshit at Work and How to Make it Go Away, and gave some thought provoking examples of worthless values statements. Here are three.

People who Act with integrity

This was Ernst & Young’s number one value at the time the company knew some its auditors were cheating on exams and did not stop it.

Safety, Quality, Integrity

Boeing’s values during the time it was hiding information from safety officials about the 737 Max, which was implicated in two fatal crashes.

What’s Right for Customers, Ethics, People as a Competitive Advantage, Leadership

Wells Fargo Bank’s, as their employees were opening millions of accounts without their customers’ knowledge.

Sweeney maintains that organizational values fall in four categories.

1) Silly Inverse Values

These are values such as integrity, ethics, and responsible. Inverse meaning that no one would ever subscribe to their inverse (dishonest, unethical, irresponsible) so that just makes them silly.

2) Delusional Values

These are aspirational but don’t reflect the real life organization. The organization may articulate critical thinking for example, but what they measure and reward is compliance, they may say they value innovation, but attempts that don’t succeed get punished.

3) Compliance Rebadged

These are things the company has to legally demonstrate compliance, so it’s just rebadging something they have to do in order to stay in business. Like cleanliness for a pharmaceutical lab would be euphonism for, “we will comply with all regulations to keep our labs free from contamination.”

4) Basic Work Stuff

Things that everyone does most of the time anyhow. Like working in teamwork or collaboration. No organization could exist if its members didn’t work and collaborate. That’s what an organization does.

What do you think?

Do people behave differently because of values a company displays on posters and coffee cups? When an organization issues its value statement, is it delusional or at best benign, or is it inspirational?

Mindshifting Educators

Mindshifting is recognizing and shifting from the mindsets that hold us back to the mindsets that push us forward. I write about mindsets, Mindshifting, learning, and education, with the hope that these posts give readers more power over their own lives and helps them give others, like their students, more power as well.

Read more from Mindshifting Educators

Hi everyone. This week we will be moving this newsletter to WordPress. You should get a post tomorrow (Tuesday, 24 June, 2025) from the new MindShiftingWithMitch.blog site, and a fuller explanation later in the week. Please check your spam folder for the email tomorrow.

We often think our biggest challenges are external—but what if the real roadblocks are in our own thinking? In my conversation with Marc Haine, I unpack some of the most common (and sneaky) mindset traps that derail progress, and I share tools I’ve used with leaders to help them move forward with clarity and purpose. This episode is full of insights you can use right away.

I love when I see really smart people explaining their work. Last night 15 educators showed and explained lesson plans on how to teach others the techniques to become resourceful, how to take control of your mind and not let circumstances dictate how you feel, think, and actl The sequence of lessons are: 1. Navigating Sensory overload with MindShifting, for 6th to adult 2. What if, a way to get unstuck, for K-5 3. Professional Development: Implementing a Choice Board for Empowering Students...